There is no shortage of reality TV shows that focus on plastic surgery as a way of improving oneself, but what effect is this having on the viewers? Teenagers make up a large percentage of the audience for these types of shows, and it is not news that teenagers are especially self-conscious of their appearance. The problem with these reality television shows is that they make happiness appear to be just a surgery away.
Charlotte Markey, an associate professor of psychology at Rutgers-Camden, along with her husband Patrick Markey of Villanova University, recently published their research on this topic in the journal, Body Image. The research found that teens who do consume these shows, will likely join the increasing ranks of people who receive plastic surgery.
“When we think of cosmetic surgery, we don’t think of it as a lifetime issue. There is lots of pressure to look a certain way and I don’t blame them for succumbing; we’re all guilty of feeling vulnerable. But what young men and women think of their bodies now will culminate over time and contribute to their overall health,” notes the Rutgers–Camden psychologist. “What troubles me is that there’s no conclusive data that cosmetic surgery even makes people happier, what has been documented is that it makes repeat customers.”
The methods were as follows:
The wife-and-husband team surveyed nearly 200 participants with an average age of 20 on their immediate responses to an ‘extreme makeover’ program or a show on home improvement – incorporated specifically to mask the intent of the study. Both men and women were included in the study and the procedures examined were ones either gender could pursue.
The results followed:
As the Rutgers–Camden researcher suspected, women were more likely to want cosmetic surgery than men and viewers of the cosmetic surgery show were more inclined to consider the procedure for themselves than those who didn’t tune in. What still shocks Markey are the handwritten responses to the cosmetic surgery show, including comments like “inspirational” and “I saw an unhappy girl get her dreams.”
The impact of these results were then discussed:
While ABC’s Extreme Makeover, which led to the Extreme Makeover-Home Edition, was cancelled in 2007, it sparked the development of several other similarly themed shows like Fox’s The Swan, the drama Nip/Tuck, MTV’s I Want a Famous Face, E’s Dr. 90210 and Oxygen’s recent Addicted to Beauty. The impact of reality television as a new media influence – regardless of topic – also raises many questions about what is being portrayed to viewers as real and indicative of everyday life.
“There is a cultural context to never be satisfied with our physical selves. It’s the rare person who is either completely oblivious or has developed such a strong counter message to not be affected, “notes Markey, the mother of a four-year-old boy and a three-year-old girl. “We need to teach children to be critical of the messages we’re receiving and tell them positive things now to foster self-esteem.”
Markey brings these cultural dialogues into her own home by explaining to her young children why Barbie is banned. “I tell them ‘no one you will ever meet in real life will ever look like her’” she says. “There are so many messages out there telling us that we need to fix ourselves, but at an early age we need to tell our kids: ‘I love you just the way you are.’”